Value Assessment

The UPMC’s insurance sales division can benefit from adopting the CRM service of Salesforce.com. Of course, when adopting new services and technology there are always costs but in this particular situation, we will show the value of this CRM service matched up against our business’ needs. The beauty of CRM technology (Salesforce in particular) is that its system has the capability to be shaped in the given organization/department’s vision. Specifically, with our group using UPMC’s insurance division for our pilot run it will serve as a good gauge on whether to expand the use of Salesforce to the rest of the organization if it goes well. UPMC may want to even outsource the implementation of salesforce.com “Companies that outsource packaged-software implementations can benefit from shorter time to implementation and lower costs as opposed to taking on these tasks in-house” (CIO.com, 2003). Salesforce ability to incorporate all of a company’s departments into one system while still providing unique departmentalized functions is key. The innovation of healthcare technology is growing more and more important each day and the implementation of successful CRM technologies is one way to do this.


In order to drive membership, increase insurance sales, and improve customer satisfaction we have identified integrating Salesforce is the best move. In the past year, UPMC observed growth in their insurance services (10% as mentioned in the Cost Analysis). With this growth comes the business needs to accommodate the growing amounts of customers and the increased sales that will come from them. UPMC’s business requires a personalized upscale CRM system that Salesforce is the best option for. Using Salesforce.com promotes a user-friendly environment that provides real-time analytics that can be extremely useful when it comes to retaining customers and bringing in new business. It stresses an importance on reducing redundancy in calling customers, which is key to retention and prospecting new business. “There are three critical actions organizations can take to encourage digital process innovation: map and then streamline select end-to-end business activities, get a clear view of how information and data are managed across the parent and target companies, and reconsider the organizational structure and operating model” (Mckinsey, 2015).

“Removing fragmentation is key to transforming healthcare. Salesforce can provide a way to track all of it. Salesforce.com creates unique identities to track complex relationships among patients, providers, and their health information data so it can be transmitted securely. Ability to share secure information reduces the need for repetitive tasks.” Find more about SalesForce's contribution in Michigan Health Network here.

UPMC’s Insurance Services Division (ISD), the largest medical insurer in western Pennsylvania, has grown to 3.2 million members and is leading the way with innovative health plans for virtually all segments of society that deliver better quality and lower costs.


UPMC’s operating revenue grew to 13 billion (800 million of this came from UPMC’s ISD), while their operating income was around 310 million (EBIDA 767 million, well above industry standard). Over the last decade, UPMC has reinvested more than 5 billion dollars to upgrade their technology, facilities, and infrastructure towards ensuring top-quality care and the best patient experience as well as long-term sustainability. This makes sense why UPMC would want to implement Salesforce.com into their systems, it fits exactly with what their organization is trying to accomplish. UPMC’s revenue increases yearly as the business grows, the ISD, in particular, is experiencing major growth, Salesforce allows the employees to manage this growth and keep growing while not becoming overwhelmed. This streamlined system can even account for potentially fewer employees needed, which would reduce expenses on salaries. Most importantly it would enhance the customer experience, and this would lead to an increase in the already impressive percentage that UPMC has in retention. The table below shows a breakdown of costs and benefits for ROI.

Salesforce.com integration into UPMC Insurance Services Division
Total Charges
Initial Investments
(418,800)one-time investment
Recurring Charges
(44,000)
yearly


Revenues
13,000
in millions


Operating Expenses
5,400
in millions


Operating Income
310
in millions

Operating Income with Investment
309
in millions


Benefits and Cost Saving Abilities with Salesforce.com *

Increase total membership
3,450,000
Salesforce would allow additional
growth even more than the 10% that UPMC
experienced in 2016 to 2017

Increase membership retention
95%-100%
Well above the industry standard of 70%

Eliminates needs for enrollment platforms

Can be costly additional charges in the range of 2 to 3 
hundred thousand dollars

Salary reductions
800,000
If successful after one year a team member from each 
lead could be eliminated (40,000 * 20 = 800,000)






* Data as per UPMC’s Fiscal Year 2016 report (UPMC, n.d.) and SalesForce’s past success (SalesForce, n.d.)

The benefits that Salesforce.com would bring to the table outweigh the costs. Eliminating fragmentation to make a more streamlined CRM system just makes sense for a Healthcare organization like UPMC. Improving upon what they stand for in giving top quality care and building the infrastructure for long-term stability is what Salesforce.com can do. The costs of implementation are there but as they are shown above they are not overwhelming. Some hidden and recurring costs will be there to be discussed but the tangible benefits outweigh the additional costs. “In the long run, you’d like to spend as little as possible on maintaining and as much as possible on new ways of providing services and using IT to compete” (Austin, 2016). Eliminating the need for separate enrollment platforms, increasing membership and retention percentages, and potentially being able to cut back on salaries all prove to be worth the investment of Salesforce.com.



References:


Mckinsey.com. (2015, July). Putting digital process innovation at the center of organizational change. Retrieved October 19, 2017, from https://www.mckinsey.com/business-functions/digital-mckinsey/our-insights/putting-digital-process-innovation-at-the-center-of-organizational-change

Salesforce. (n.d.) Salesforce for Healtcare and Life Sciences. Retrieved from https://www.salesforce.com/solutions/industries/healthcare/health-cloud/?d=7010M000001yNc2

CIO.com. (2003, February 1st). Save Time and Money: Outsource Software Implementation. Retrieved October 17, 2017, from https://www.cio.com/article/2440218/outsourcing/save-time-and-money--outsource-software-implementation.html

Austin, Robert D., et al. “Chapter 4 Cost of IT.” The Adventures of an IT Leader, Harvard Business School Publishing, 2016, pp. 65.

UPMC. (n.d.). Financial results FY 2017-Q2. Retrieved from http://www.upmc.com/about/finances/Documents/fy2017-q2-financial-results-media-slides.pdf


UPMC. (n.d.). UPMC Annual Report 2015. Retrieved from https://www.upmchealthplan.com/about/UPMC15_AnnualReport.pdf

No comments:

Post a Comment